Holbrook, NY — Momentum Score, Home Values & Best-For

All states·New York·Holbrook

Suffolk County · New York-Newark-Jersey City · population 26,487

Small-town feel

Overview Cost of living Moving guide

View watchlist →

Hot

Momentum score · 0–100

Where Holbrook stands

At or near all-time high. home values up 4.9% in the last year. rents up 7.4% in the last year.

Median home $647,475

1-year +4.9%

5-yr CAGR +6.2%

vs 5-yr peak -0.1%

Home value trajectory · last 10 years

Zillow ZHVI · monthly

Lifestyle scores

🚶

Walkability

32/100

Very car-dependent

Estimated from population density. Higher = denser, more amenities within walking distance.

🚉

Public transit

15/100

Transit limited

Curated list of major US transit systems + population-based estimate. Higher = real subway/rail/bus options.

💻

Remote work fit

59/100

Workable for remote workers

Composite of city size, housing cost, state tax structure, and region's remote-work track record.

Scores are heuristic estimates from population density, state, and known transit/walkable cities. Not based on a paid Walk Score / Transit Score API — see methodology for the formula.

Rent trajectory · last 5 years

Zillow ZORI · monthly

Home value vs rent · indexed to 100

Both rebased at first month of ZORI data (~2015)

Rent vs buy

Price-to-rent ratio: 19.1

Lean buy

At a 19.1 price-to-rent ratio, Holbrook is in the 'depends on horizon' zone. Buy if you'll be there 5+ years and value flexibility on the home; rent if you might move, want zero maintenance friction, or expect rates to drop.

How the momentum score breaks down

methodology →

Home YoY

75 · w22%

Home 5-yr CAGR

71 · w22%

Distance from peak

90 · w18%

Rent YoY

85 · w12%

Home 10-yr CAGR

70 · w10%

Long thesis

Holbrook has held up across the cycle: home values at $647,475 with +6.2% 5-year CAGR. The bull case is structural — population, location, employer base — and holds even if next year's print is soft.

Short thesis

Holbrook's bear case is the boring one: the cycle is real and any market that's run hard can stall. Watch for slowing population growth, rising days-on-market, or builder discounts as the early warning signals.

About Holbrook

Holbrook is a city in Suffolk County, New York, with an estimated population of 26,487. It anchors the New York-Newark-Jersey City metro area. The median home value in Holbrook is $647,475 as of 2026-04, up 4.9% over the last 12 months. Over the last five years, home values have averaged +6.2% annual growth, with prices at or near the 5-year peak. Rents in Holbrook average $2,818 per month, up 7.4% year-over-year. The composite momentum score is 78 of 100 (Hot). Buyers should expect competition and limited negotiation room in this market.

▲ Bull case

●Healthy 5-year run: +6.2% annualized over 5 years, outpacing US inflation.

●Quiet strength: +4.9% over the trailing year — not a melt-up, but the market is bid.

●Held the highs: currently -0.1% from the 5-year peak — this market refused to give back gains.

●Hot rental market: rents up 7.4% YoY — landlords have pricing power, supports new investment math.

▼ Bear case

●Rental squeeze: rents up 7.4% YoY — tenants face tough renewals. Affordability deteriorating fast.

○Local nuance: city-level data smooths over neighborhood differences. School zones, HOA rules, and street-level character matter — visit before deciding.

Playbook

Buyer

Expect competition, escalation clauses, and pressure to waive inspections. Make your strongest offer up front — Hot markets reward decisiveness, not negotiation. If you can't write a clean offer, you may not be the best fit for this market right now.

Seller

Price slightly above recent comps and let multiple offers work. Days-on-market should be short. Don't accept the first offer in the first 48 hours unless it's significantly above ask.

Investor

Cap rates will look ugly in a Hot market — your thesis has to be appreciation, not yield. Don't expect cash flow; expect to ride the trend and exit before it stalls.

Local safety & alerts

No active National Weather Service alerts for Suffolk County right now.

NWS active alerts (NY)New York Emergency Management How to prepare (NWS)

Public-safety links are official .gov sources, not curated by us. Suffolk County routes NWS alerts; check the state EM portal for non-weather emergencies.